Leased worker or posted worker: the difference and why it changes the tax

Two Estonian companies send the same welder to the same Finnish shipyard. In one case Finland taxes his wages from the first day, and in the other it may not tax them at all. The difference is who directs the work.

What is a posted worker?

A posted worker is an employee of a company in one country who works in another country for a limited time. The Finnish occupational safety and health authority names three forms of posting: subcontracting, a transfer inside a group of companies, and temporary agency work. So a leased worker is one kind of posted worker.

What is a leased worker?

In staff leasing, also called temporary agency work, the employer hires the worker out to another company, the user. The employer pays the wages. The user directs and supervises the daily work. In Estonian law the leasing company is a rendiagentuur and the work is renditöö.

Subcontracting is the other way round. The Estonian company agrees to deliver a result, for example to install the ventilation in a building. It sends its own people, directs their work itself and answers for the result.

How do you tell which one you have?

The name of the contract does not decide it. What decides is how the work is done in practice.

QuestionStaff leasingSubcontracting
Who directs the daily work?The clientThe Estonian employer
What does the client pay for?Hours workedAn agreed result
Who answers for the quality of the work?The clientThe Estonian employer
Whose tools and materials are used?Usually the client'sUsually the employer's

These are practical signs, not a legal test. If the answers are mixed, treat the case as open and have it checked before the first invoice.

Why does it change the income tax in Finland?

According to the Finnish Tax Administration, a leased worker who comes from Estonia pays tax to Finland from the first working day. For a worker on the employer's own contract the usual treaty rule applies. Finland does not tax the wages if the worker stays for at most 183 days, the employer is not Finnish, and the wages are not a cost of a permanent establishment in Finland.

Say a welder works in Turku for four months. As a leased worker he pays Finnish tax on all four months and needs a Finnish tax card. On his employer's own subcontract, with no permanent establishment in Finland, his wages stay taxable in Estonia. Sources: the Finnish Tax Administration on foreign employers that lease employees to Finland (in Finnish) and on the taxation of employees from other countries.

What else changes?

  • Reports in Finland. For a leased worker the employer files a start notification within five calendar days after the first wage payment. It also reports the wages to the Finnish Incomes Register within five days of each payment.
  • The invoice to the client. If the leasing company is not in the Finnish prepayment register, the client withholds 13% tax at source from the payment.
  • Registration in Estonia. A company that hires out workers files a business activity notice before it starts. Leased work can be done only under an employment contract.
  • Daily allowance. A worker hired out to one place abroad for a long period is not on a business trip, so the allowance cannot be paid tax free.

Sources: Labour Inspectorate review of staff leasing and Tax and Customs Board, daily allowance for a worker in staff leasing (both in Estonian).

What stays the same?

  • Social tax. With a valid A1 certificate the worker stays in the Estonian system in both cases.
  • Notification in Finland. Both are posted workers, so the Finnish authority is notified before the work starts and a representative is named.
  • Finnish terms of work. Pay follows the generally binding collective agreement of the sector in both cases.
  • Estonian payroll. The employment contract, the employment register entry and the monthly TSD are needed in both cases.

Source: the Finnish occupational safety and health authority on the posted worker.

What should you do before the first job?

  1. Write down who will direct the daily work and what the client pays for.
  2. Make the contract with the client match that answer.
  3. Check the Finnish tax position of each worker before the first wage payment.
  4. Apply for the A1 certificate for each worker.
  5. Tell your payroll provider which workers are leased and which are on your own contract.

We set up the Estonian payroll for both cases and tell you when a question belongs to an adviser in Finland. The full list of steps is in Sending workers from Estonia to Finland, and the payroll side is in Payroll for a staffing company. See also payroll services.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a leased worker and a posted worker?

A leased worker is hired out to a client who directs the daily work. A posted worker in subcontracting works under the direction of his or her own employer. Both are posted workers when the work is done in another country.

Is a leased worker taxed in Finland from the first day?

Yes, when the worker comes from Estonia. The Finnish Tax Administration lists Estonia among the countries whose leased workers pay tax to Finland from the first working day.

Does the name of the contract decide whether it is staff leasing?

No. What matters is how the work is done in practice, above all who directs the daily work.

Does an Estonian leasing company have to register its activity?

Yes. A company that hires out workers files a business activity notice in Estonia before it starts.

Is the A1 certificate different for leased workers?

No. The same certificate is used, and with a valid A1 the worker stays in the Estonian social security system.

Tagsleased worker vs posted workertemporary agency work Estoniastaff leasing Finland taxsubcontracting or staff leasing

This page is for general information. For a better answer, get in touch and receive a personal recommendation.

Back to all articles

Get a fixed quote for your company

Complete the request in about two minutes. Receive a written quote usually within one working day.