Say an Estonian company hires someone who lives in Finland. Or an existing employee moves to Spain and keeps working, or a developer on the payroll spends half the year with family in Germany. In every version, the owner asks us the same thing: do we just keep running Estonian payroll? The answer is sometimes yes and often no, and it has almost nothing to do with how the contract is written.
Social security is decided in one country only, and work decides which
Social security is paid in one country only, and that is usually the country where the work is done. Inside the EU, the EEA (European Economic Area) and Switzerland, this is coordinated by Regulation (EC) 883/2004. Its first principle is that a person is covered in one member state at a time, never two and never none. Article 11(3)(a) then gives the default rule: the competent state is the one where the work is actually done.
In plain terms, the competent state is the country whose social security system covers the person. The default rule does not look at where the employer is registered. It also ignores where the contract was signed, which law it names and which currency pays it. An employee at a desk in Helsinki is working in Finland, whatever her Estonian employer would prefer. Unless one of the exceptions below applies, the Finnish system is competent, and the Estonian employer has to arrange it.
Income tax follows a different rule, which is why people get this wrong
Income tax follows a different set of rules, and mixing the two up is the most common error we see. It is an understandable one: payroll feels like one thing, so people assume one answer covers it. Social security follows Regulation 883/2004. Employment income tax follows the double tax treaty between the two countries, normally Article 15. That article uses the familiar test of physical presence and the 183 day threshold.
So an employee can quite correctly be in the Estonian social security system while their salary is taxable in their country of residence, or the reverse. Neither outcome is a mistake or a loophole. It is simply what the two sets of rules produce when you apply them separately, which is what you must do.
Do not reason from one answer to the other. Work out the social security country under Regulation 883/2004. Then work out the income tax country under the treaty, as a separate exercise. If you get the first right and assume the second follows, you can end up owing withheld tax in a country where you never registered.
Estonia joined the cross-border telework agreement on 1 February 2026
Estonia joined the agreement with effect from 1 February 2026, and it is the newest and most useful part of the picture. Guides written before this year may not mention it yet.
Its full name is the multilateral Framework Agreement on the application of Article 16(1) of Regulation 883/2004 to habitual cross-border telework. Telework here means working remotely, usually from home, using digital tools. The agreement has been in force since 1 July 2023, and Finland, Germany and Spain have all signed it from that first day. It took effect for Estonia later.
Under it, an employee can telework from their country of residence for less than 50% of total working time. Estonia, as the employer's state, then stays the competent social security system. Before the agreement, the threshold for a person working in two states was 25%. So one day a week at home in another country was often enough to move the whole case abroad. Now there is real room: two days a week of telework from Helsinki or Madrid can stay inside the Estonian system.
Three conditions matter in practice. First, it is not automatic: the employer and the employee apply for it jointly. Second, you still need an A1 certificate (explained below), so the paperwork stays the same and only the outcome improves. Third, both countries must be signatories. For an Estonian employer, that means the relevant date is February 2026, not July 2023.
The three routes that keep an employee inside the Estonian system
There are exactly three routes, and they do not overlap. The first useful step is to work out which one you are in.
| Route | Legal basis | The limit | Typical case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Posting | Reg 883/2004 Art 12 | Up to 24 months | Sent abroad for a defined project |
| Work in two or more states | Reg 883/2004 Art 13, threshold in Reg 987/2009 Art 14(8) | Under 25% of working time or pay in the state of residence | Travels constantly, lives in one country, works across several |
| Habitual cross-border telework | Framework Agreement under Art 16(1) | Under 50% of total working time in the state of residence | Lives abroad, works from home part of the week |
Posting, under Article 12, is the oldest and narrowest route. It runs up to 24 months, and only where all of the following apply. The employer normally carries out substantial activity in the posting state. The direct employment relationship continues throughout. The expected duration is under 24 months from the start. The worker is not replacing another posted person. Going beyond 24 months is possible, but it needs a specific Article 16 agreement between the two states. That is a negotiation rather than a form.
Work in two or more member states, under Article 13, depends on whether a substantial part of the activity happens in the state of residence. Substantial has a fixed meaning here. Article 14(8) of Implementing Regulation (EC) 987/2009 sets it at 25% or more of working time or remuneration. Below 25% in the country of residence, the employer's state stays competent. At or above it, the country of residence takes the whole case, including the work done elsewhere.
Do this arithmetic carefully, because it is unforgiving. One day a week at home is 20% and stays inside the employer's state. Two days is 40% and does not. The telework agreement was written to soften exactly that sharp jump. That is why, now that Estonia has joined, the 50% route is usually the better one to aim for.
The A1 certificate, and what the absence of one actually means
None of the three routes works just because you say so. The document that proves which country covers a person is the A1 certificate, formally Portable Document A1. In Estonia it is issued by the Social Insurance Board (Sotsiaalkindlustusamet). You apply online through eesti.ee or on paper. An electronic application that meets the conditions is normally answered by the next working day, and other cases take up to 30 days.
With an answer by the next working day, there is no good reason to work without one. An A1 is not a formality to catch up on later. It is the evidence a foreign authority or inspector looks for. Without it, the default rule applies again: the employee works in their own country, and the employer owes contributions there. Apply before the arrangement starts, not after someone asks.
Finland, which is the case we are asked about most
Finland is the case we are asked about most. Estonia and Finland are 85 kilometres apart, and many Estonian companies have someone living on the other side. So it helps to be concrete about the Finnish position when no A1 keeps the person in Estonia.
The Finnish Centre for Pensions states the baseline plainly. An employee working in Finland must be insured in Finland, whatever their nationality and wherever the employer is based. The foreign employer must arrange and pay Finnish statutory social insurance, including earnings-related pension insurance. It must also report the earnings to the Finnish Incomes Register. There is one piece of flexibility. The employer may agree that the employee takes out the statutory insurance in Finland on the employer's behalf, under a power of attorney.
That is the default, and it is what an A1 replaces. With the A1, the person stays in the Estonian system. Without it, the Estonian company has taken on a Finnish payroll obligation, often without noticing until some months in.
Germany and Spain: what we can and cannot tell you
Germany and Spain have both been signatories to the telework agreement since July 2023. So the 50% route is open for an Estonian employer with staff in either country. The basic picture is the same as for Finland. Without an A1, the country where the work happens expects to insure the person, and the obligation sits with the employer.
We do not describe the detailed German and Spanish requirements here, such as registers, deadlines and filings. We have not verified them, and guesswork on foreign social insurance procedure would not help you. What we do is settle the Estonian side and the Regulation 883/2004 question. We also tell you clearly when you need an adviser in the other country. For a Spanish or German payroll registration, that point comes early.
Permanent establishment, a risk that is easy to overlook
There is a second question behind the payroll one. An employee working from home in another country can sometimes create a taxable presence there for the employer. This is called a permanent establishment. It is a corporate tax problem rather than a payroll one, and a much more expensive one.
We deliberately do not give a rule or a number of days for this, because there is no reliable one. It depends on the facts, above all on what the person actually does. The main question is whether they habitually conclude contracts or act as a dependent agent of the company. The risk is real, and the other country assesses it under its own law and the relevant treaty. A sales role abroad deserves a proper look, while a back office role usually needs less worry. If the role is commercial and the arrangement is permanent, get it checked before it has run for a year.
What to do, in order
- Map the work. Write down where the work physically happens, in days per month. Record where the person sits, not what the contract says.
- Pick the route. Work out which of the three routes fits, if any: posting under 24 months, under 25% in the state of residence, or under 50% telework under the Framework Agreement.
- Apply for the A1 through the Social Insurance Board before the arrangement starts.
- Check income tax separately. Work out the income tax country under the treaty. Do not assume it matches the social security answer.
- Get local advice where needed. If the other country is competent for anything, engage an adviser there. That step cannot be handled from Tallinn.
- Check the permanent establishment risk. Ask whether the role creates one, and treat a commercial role differently from an administrative one.
We handle steps one to four, and the Estonian payroll that follows from them. We run the cross-border assessment before the first payment, not after a foreign authority raises it. Getting this wrong does not mean a fine. It means a backdated social insurance liability in a country where you are not registered. Once the structure is settled, our payroll service can run the Estonian side.
If what you actually want is to hire someone abroad with no Estonian connection at all, tell us early. Sometimes an Estonian employment contract is the wrong tool, and you need a local employer of record instead. That is a company in the other country that employs the person on your behalf. We do not offer that service, and we will not talk you out of it.
Frequently asked questions
My employee lives in Finland and works for my Estonian company. Where are the payroll taxes paid?
By default in Finland, because Regulation 883/2004 makes the country where the work is done the competent one. The exceptions are a posting of up to 24 months, or work in two or more states with under 25% in the country of residence. A third is telework of under 50% under the Framework Agreement, which Estonia joined on 1 February 2026. Each needs an A1 certificate.
How much can an employee work from another country before the social security moves?
It depends which rule applies. For a person working in two or more member states, the threshold is 25% of working time or remuneration in the country of residence. It is set by Article 14(8) of Regulation 987/2009. Under the cross-border telework Framework Agreement, the limit is less than 50% of total working time, which is far more generous.
Is Estonia part of the EU cross-border telework agreement?
Yes, with effect from 1 February 2026. Finland, Germany and Spain have been signatories since 1 July 2023. Because Estonia joined later, guidance for Estonian employers written before 2026 may not mention the 50% route at all.
Who issues the A1 certificate in Estonia and how long does it take?
The Social Insurance Board (*Sotsiaalkindlustusamet*). You apply through eesti.ee or on paper. An electronic application that meets the conditions is normally answered by the next working day. Other applications can take up to 30 days. Apply before the arrangement starts, not after.
Can income tax and social security be due in different countries?
Yes, and this is normal rather than an anomaly. Social security is decided by Regulation 883/2004 and income tax by the double tax treaty, usually Article 15 with its 183 day test. They are separate questions with separate answers, so each has to be worked out on its own.
Does an employee working from home abroad create a permanent establishment for my company?
Sometimes. It depends on the facts rather than on a day count. What matters is what the person does, particularly whether they habitually conclude contracts or act as a dependent agent. The other country assesses it under its own law and the relevant treaty. A commercial role abroad deserves a proper review, while an administrative one usually needs less.
Tagsemployee working from another country payrollA1 certificate Estoniawhere is social tax paid remote work EUEstonian company employee abroad obligations
This page is for general information. For a better answer, get in touch and receive a personal recommendation.